What is artistry?

While browsing the Gymternet, there is always a topic I see being debated quite a bit- artistry. What exactly is it? Some people will tell you it's the classical, elegant and graceful movements usually reserved for the ballet stage including an incredible toe point, stick straight legs and graceful arms. Others will tell you it's all about showing expression and loving what you do, regardless of the choreography you're given. The question of whether the "artistry" have been taken out of artistic gymnastics is never ending. The sport is always changing, and to keep up with the very best, you need to keep up with the increasing demands of difficulty. It's an on going debate and honestly, nobody is right.  I've seen SO MANY interesting view points on this topic, and I wanted to share some of them with you. Feel free to voice your opinions in the comment section below.

Definition of artistry:

Artistic workmanship, effect, or quality

Having or revealing nature creative skill

Excellence in execution

Photo Credit: Thomas Schreyer

Your definitions of artistry:






My Definition

Artistry can be a pretty complicated thing. In the real world, everyone has there own idea of what "beautiful" looks like and gymnastics is no exception. What appeals to my eyes, may not appeal to yours. And THAT to me, is the beautiful thing about artistry. To me, artistry is whatever you interpret it to be. It comes in many different forms. I think the biggest misconception is that you have to be a ballerina to be classified as artistic. I mean let's face it, Aly Raisman will NEVER be able to move like Aliya Mustafina. So why should she try to put together a balletic "artistic" routine when that just isn't her style? You can't force artistry. It has to come from within.You can tell when a gymnast puts passion behind her movements, and it's captivating to watch regardless of how graceful she is. Some people (the Russians in particular) are better at selling their routines. They clearly have hours of ballet training behind them and they focus on detail. They are performers. But at the same time, have you seen Lloimincia Hall?! That girl is fierce and she OWNS that floor every time she steps out there. She would look silly doing the choreography that the Russians do. She has to work with what she was given (which is a muscular build and outstanding personality) Might as well put it to good use! Artistry is all about being creative, and expressing yourself. In whatever way that may be.

Photo Credit: Chris Parent 

The code of points doesn't ask gymnast's to dance like ballerina's, it asks them to perform. Judges want to see original elements and for the gymnast to express and interpret their music well. The ability to preform comes with time. You look at many of the juniors out on the floor now, and they look scared to death. Gymnasts who mindlessly preform their routines, are the ones with no artistry. I could name you a bunch of people (mainly U.S juniors) who haven't quite come out of their shell yet. And to be honest, their routines are boring to watch. They execute the movements rather then preform them. Now look at someone like Jordyn Wieber. I happen to LOVE her floor routine (I'm not being biased either!) I've seen so many people say that Jordyn isn't artistic. Yeah I agree, she's no ballerina but she does have clean lines, great energy, and you can tell that she enjoys her routine. That floor routine fits her personal style SO well. She's spot on with the music throughout the entire routine (which is hard considering it's fast pace), she maintains a high energy level (always with a smile), as well as clean/precise dance movements ALL while throwing some huge tumbling passes. THAT to me is preforming, maybe in a different way then Aliya. But it works for Jordyn.

Photo Credit: Steve Mullensky

I think it's important to point out that ballet is the heart of Russian culture. You can see the hours of ballet training in every movement they make. From the toes, to the fingertips. For as long as I can remember, the Russian's have been known for their beautiful gymnastics. I wish other gymnasts would pay as much attention to detail as they do because it certainly has it's benefits. The USA on the other hand, is all about variety and individual expression. You see power and athleticism, as well as grace and beauty. It truly is the best of both worlds.

Photo Credit: Heather Maynez

Do I think the artistry have been taken out of artistic gymnastics? Well, with out a doubt gymnastics is different now then it was back in the 80's. But you have to keep in mind that with time comes changes (such as equipment and requirements for difficulty) I'd LOVE to see some of the unique skills preformed back in the 80's being used out on the floor again. Is is worth the risk? Absolutely, and I think a gymnast who takes the time to create unique and intricate routines (while maintaining a high level of difficulty) should be rewarded. As long as the athlete has fun, engages the audience, and brings their own personal style to the routine, I enjoy watching it.

Here are some of my favorite artistic routines:

Shantessa Pama



                           

I always appreciated Shantessa's style of gymnastics because she was so unique. Her routines were always different from what we typically saw and that is why she stands out, even to this day. You can tell she put a lot of thought into making her routines original. I really wish we could see this more often!



         

I absolutely love Beth's routine because it keeps me on edge. Everyone in the audience is engaged in her routine and she always leaves us wondering "what will she do next?!" The energy and ingenuity of this routine is incredible! Props to Beth for her creativity.


        
 
I love the fact that Peng Peng takes risks in this routine. She does a tremendous job of adding her own personal style to this and it's one of those routines that leave people talking. Peng Peng is remembered for her unique skills and classic style on every event.

                                   

Charlotte Mackie also does a great job of bringing originality to the balance beam! She has some really cool combinations and overall this routine is very entertaining.


         

Ksenia's floor work is absolutely stunning, not to mention the phenomenal choreography. A post talking about artistry would not be complete without mentioning Ksenia. I don't think there's much more to say!

Some other gymnasts who I think do a fantastic job of bringing emotion and creativity to their work are: Anastasia Grishina, Sabrina Vega, Ana Porgras, Sui Lu, Catalina Ponor, Lauren Mitchell and Jordyn Wieber


What do you guys think? Is artistry going instinct? Let me know how you feel below.